Every time we see a Janet Jackson boob or the FCC passes out fines, the Puritans and our puritan heritage. Well, stop it. It’s not their fault. The Puritans were Congregationalists. Orthodoxy and congregational governance don’t mix. The famed Salem witch trials reflect the breakdown of Calvinist orthodoxy. Every time you see a 2nd or 3rd Congregational church in New England, it’s because the founders broke from the first which had to add that number to its name.
The so-called Puritanism arises mainly from evangelical protestants and conservative Roman Catholics. The irony is that the so-called Southern Baptists are an enormous part of this cohort. And they don’t know their own heritage! If one looks at protestant governance, it is a continuum of devolution of Roman Catholic hierarchy ranging from Episcopal to the virtual anarchy of the Baptists who believed in the priesthood of the baptized. The notion that a Baptist denomination could have disciplinary powers over its members or congregations is a true oxymoron.
The lack of understanding of history is breathtaking. From those who call themselves `conservatives,’ it is frightening and fascistic.