Randy Brock releases health care plan — under cover of darkness

Hey, remember back in late May, when Randy Brock offered a sneak preview of his health care plan? His free-market alternative to the big-government, budget-bustin’, granny-killin’ Shumlin plan?

The one he’d been working on with the likes of El Jefe General John McClaughry and Tarren Bragdon, the man responsible for Maine Governor Paul LePage’s rather disastrous health care plan?

Remember that Brock said he’d unveil the full plan sometime in June?

And then, silence?

Well, Randy’s finally released the Kraken. In the weirdest possible way, as Peter Hirschfeld of the Vermont Press Bureau entertainingly notes:

We anticipated a glitzy, glamorous rollout for the plan, which is, very broadly speaking, a free-market alternative to the single-payer system favored by Gov. Peter Shumlin. Or at least a press conference, to draw TV cameras and front-page headlines, which he easily could have gotten.

Instead, “The Brock Health Care Vision: A 100% Solution,” rolled in unannounced to reporters’ inboxes at a time when many might have already called it a day.

Hard to make heads or tails of the strategy yet, but Brock obviously isn’t looking to make this plan the cornerstone of his campaign.

He also released it, intentionally or not, during a news cycle that’s going to be dominated by the fallout from the Progressive Party’s gubernatorial primary.

Hirschfeld’s explanation is the only one I can think of for this underwhelming rollout. Which is awfully damn pathetic, considering that Brock has made health-care reform — or at least criticism of Shumlin’s plan — a cornerstone of his campaign.  

At first glance, one can understand why this proposal might not look like a winner. It’s a lot like LePage’s, which has led to lower premiums for some (the young and healthy) but much higher premiums for others (the older and sicker, or those in high-risk occupations), and allowed insurers all kinds of regulatory leeway to offer really crappy coverage at relatively low cost.

Brock’s plan would allow consumers to buy insurance across state lines — because hey, it worked so well with credit-card issuers, who flooded the market with attractive-looking deals with all kinds of hidden costs and charges, deceptive interest rates, and unreadably dense terms of service. (What’s in your wallet?) Not to mention the big national mortgage mills that precipitated the 2008 crash by littering the landscape with bad debt.

He would also greatly loosen the rules on “community rating,” which forces insurers to bundle low-risk and high-risk customers into the same pool, thus leveling prices. As in Maine, loosening the rules would lower rates for the young and healthy, but raise them for the older, sicker, and more at-risk. (Lumbermen take note.)

The full plan, including all sorts of dandy conservative rhetoric (bureaucrats bad! Free market good!), can be read at Randy’s campaign website. Should you wish to.  

3 thoughts on “Randy Brock releases health care plan — under cover of darkness

  1. My reading of the term “free market” (as opposed to “fair market”) is, “Robber barons: free to lie, cheat, extort and steal with utter impunity.”

  2. Check out this bullet from Mr. Brock’s “Plan”

    Gradually reduce and eventually eliminate the vicious cycle of the cost shift under which government programs (Medicaid, VHAP, Dr. Dinosaur, Catamount) systematically underpay providers, who in turn shift the uncompensated costs to private insurance customers. This shift makes private insurance less affordable, creating more uninsured people, and driving more people into underfunded government health care programs. Providers would need to agree to reduce the present cost shift to private insurance by the approximate amount of the increased state payments.

    This gem is hidden under the heading “PROTECT PATIENTS WITH REASONABLE RULES” on page four of Brock’s five-and-a-quarter page “Health Care Plan”.

    Mr. Brock plans to decrease the burden he claims (without evidence) that Medicaid, VHAP, Dr. Dinosaur [SIC], Catamount place on the privately insured due to cost shifting, by increasing the payments these programs make to providers as long as they promise not to continue to shift their losses onto the privately insured. What the…? Who will pay for the increased funding for physicians for these programs? All of us, not just those who have private insurance. GENIUS!

    In addition, it doesn’t bode well for the candidate if Mr. Brock can’t even correctly identify and spell the name of the very successful healthcare program that currently provides necessary health care coverage for nearly 60,000 of our state’s children.

    The program is called Dr. DYNASAUR, but with this single bullet Mr. Brock has shown that it’s his thinking that’s the “Dinosaur” in the room.

Comments are closed.