Advocacy on the cheap

Anti-health care reform activist Darcie Johnston has taken a short break from updating her Facebook page and then deleting it, to produce a couple of new radio ads for her lobbying group “Vermonters for Health Care Freedom.” It must have been a short break indeed, because they are about the worst, most poorly produced radio spots I’ve ever heard. And I’ve worked at some rinky-dink stations in my day.

The ads target (respectively) Representatives Paul Poirier (I-Barre) and Mark Woodward (D-Johnson), pressuring them to support legislation that would force the Shumlin Administration to shorten its timeline for preparing a final health care reform package, so the details would be available before the November election. The ads complain that “Governor Shumlin and the Democrat legislators are trying to pull a fast one” by delaying the details until after November, and urge listeners to contact Poirier or Woodward.  

But the ads are almost unlistenable. There’s no background music; it’s just a woman reading copy for a minute. Poorly-written copy at that. The woman (I suspect it’s Johnson herself) is obviously untrained in speaking on radio; the emphasis is all over the place, the delivery is forced and too fast, there are odd pauses and breaths, and the tone is abrasive. There’s an audible hum in the background, which means it wasn’t recorded in a professional environment.

Johnston also issued a news release trumpeting the new ads, under the title “Vermonters for Health Care Freedom goes to the air waves to encourage Representatives Poirier and Woodward to support releasing health care financing before November election.” Which tells me two things: (1) she doesn’t know how to spell “airwaves,” and (2) she doesn’t know how to write a good headline.

I hate to give Johnston any more pageviews, but I recommend listening to one of the spots as a prime example of how not to do political advertising.

I hope her undisclosed donors didn’t pay too much for these ads. Whatever they paid, they didn’t get their money’s worth.

Addendum 2/16: The Vermont Democratic Party has issued a press release about Darcie Johnston’s unfortunate Facebook post, readable at Vermont Digger which notes that she has close and longstanding ties to State Senator (and presumptive Republican Gubernatorial candidate) Randy Brock. It characterizes her as a paid Brock advisor since 2004. If true, then Senator Brock might want to rethink the relationship. The Facebook post and these awful ads certainly call into question her qualifications as a political operator.

By the way, Johnston posted a comment under the press release, in which she basically falls back on the “I was only kidding” defense. She actually says “I meant no offense to ANYONE.” (Caps hers.) So I guess it’s our fault if we’re offended. Again, is this someone you’d want working for you if you had serious political aspirations?

2 thoughts on “Advocacy on the cheap

  1. I can’t imagine a stupider Rep to target than Mark Woodward.  

    A) He’s one of the least vulnerable Reps in the House.  He’s fought much tougher battles than this one & been re-elected to that seat over and over again.  

    B) He’s a staunch supporter of universal healthcare

    He could get a million phone calls from anti-healthcare people.  He’s not changing his position on this.  And the chances of defeating him at the ballot box are very slim.  

    If anything, this ad campaign will just make him more popular amongst his constituents.  

    This ad campaign is just ridiculous.  

  2. I know representative Woodward.  I like him.  He is this plain kind of guy that does not seem entirely comfortable in a tie, and seems more at home in a Carhart working guy’s coat.  Yet, he is as smart as that proverbial whip.  He and I listened to one of this Bruce Lisman ads in his car one day in the parking lot by the statehouse.  He is a dedicated and staunch supporter of universal healthcare and is more than tough enough to be moved by that stupid ad of Darcie johnston’s.  I do not know how strong he is in his district, though will take the previous post’s word for it, but he is a great rep and person and is dedicated to health care for all of us.  

Comments are closed.