With the ever-increasing proliferation of hybrid and other high-mileage vehicles, federal gas tax revenue is in the decline. Transportation Secretary Roy LaHood is tossing around the idea of a “mileage tax” to replace the current system, a bad idea for several reasons, both of which summed up aptly in the first paragraph right here:
A tentative plan in Massachusetts to use GPS chips in vehicles to charge motorists by the mile has drawn complaints from drivers who say it's an Orwellian intrusion by government into the lives of citizens. Other motorists say it eliminates an incentive to drive more fuel-efficient cars since gas guzzlers will be taxed at the same rate as fuel sippers.
Besides a VMT tax, more tolls for highways and bridges and more government partnerships with business to finance transportation projects are other funding options, LaHood, one of two Republicans in President Barack Obama's Cabinet, said in the interview Thursday.
“What I see this administration doing is this — thinking outside the box on how we fund our infrastructure in America,” he said.
Apparently, LaHood is open to this idea, as are several states. Now, I know, the gas tax as it is currently structured is a regressive tax, but given the choice of the government being able to track everyplace I go in my car or raising the current tax, I'll go with the latter. Simply put, there is no way in hell I'm going to allow the government to be able to track me in that way, and this one will reverberate across the left/right spectrum in terms of opposition due to privacy concerns. Aside from what the government can do with it, there's a ton of opportunities for abuse if the information is compromised and falls into the hands of private detectives, marketers, etc. No thanks.
Perhaps, 5 or so years from now, after more people have switched to more efficient vehicles, a mileage tax could make sense, but it can be done in a way that is less intrusive, perhaps at vehicle inspection every year or something. But tracking vehicles in this way is ridiculous.
(Poll beneath the jump)
UPDATED: White House says it isn't happening.