(Semi-update disclosure…. I tweaked some text below to better make my point. Ah, the power of being a site admin…)
We needed a real poll and here it is, reflecting the change in the air that has been present ever since the Rasmussen fiasco of a poll gave Pollina a new boost. From WCAX:
The poll shows Republican Jim Douglas has 47 percent of the vote, Democrat Gaye Symington 24 percent and Independent Anthony Pollina a very close third with 23 percent.
So what’s with the big change? Although such generalizations are never absolute, there’s a real difference in the hardcore supporters of Symington vs. Pollina. Symington’s crowd really has its eyes on only one prize, and they’ve become utterly deflated as they’ve seen that gap continue to be so large. Morale is in the crapper.
Pollina supporters, on the other hand, are often just as passionate (sometimes more so) about beating Democrats as Republicans. So the then-illusory prospect offered to them by Rasmussen of beating the Democrat fired them up as much as anything. Morale is soaring, and what was illusory is illusory no longer.
And many in the neutral zone of the left are likely responding to that difference – exuberance versus glumness. Moths prefer the flame to the sad clown (is that a mixed metaphor? What is that?).
But I think it brings to light the Douglas strategy of late very, very clearly. A strategy conventional-wisdom-gurus Eric Davis and Garrison Nelson apparently haven’t figured out yet. And its smart.
The notion that Douglas is afraid of Pollina is something I can hardly type without cracking up. Republicans are the last people who think Pollina could ever be elected Governor – especially over Douglas (hey, don’t shoot the messenger, here…). But they are concerned about the prospect of their man Jim losing in the Legislature. If he comes in under 50%, there are lots of Democratic legislators just itching at the chance to vote him out. Trust me.
But here’s the thing: they know if Symington doesn’t come within 10 points of a victory, Dem legislators will be hard pressed to justify electing her. And I think its safe to say that neither Symington nor Pollina will be willing to help give the other public support and cover under such a sceario if they come in at number 3 (which is revolting, frankly).
So they’ve figured out the obvious – Symington’s support is inversely proportional to Pollina’s. Therefore, if they don’t consider Pollina a threat, and Symington has to be kept as far out of range as possible, ignoring Pollina becomes just plain stupid. Run against both of them, equating them and raising Pollina’s profile – insure a low split. The most basic of math, and way too easy. If they were scared of Pollina, they wouldn’t be running these kinds of ads, they’d be hitting him on the Milk Company and the Campaign Finance flip-flops. They’d be mean.
This stuff? Well look at the reaction. It’s just pumping Pollina up.
The only – and I mean only – way around this is if Symington and Pollina make a pledge now to throw in with the number two in the legislature and start priming their voters and nervous legislators for the possibility. That becomes a net plus for us because if either of them were running at Douglas head on, it seems highly unlikely that they could keep him below 50% on their own. Both of their negatives are too high.
Fat freakin’ chance of that happening, though.