We’re about to go into another news cycle of debate about the death penalty, in light of recent news. It won’t be fun.
Let me be clear; there are certain crimes that generate a reflexive, almost instinctive reaction. At least that’s how they feel to me, and looking at others, I expect that’s a fair description. Crimes that seem to demand the death of the perpetrator. Sometimes they may seem to demand the torture of the perpetrator. Or maybe (and I’m not trying to be funny – I’m dead serious), a death by slow torture. And by slow, I may mean over as long a period as possible. I’d be lying if I said I didn’t feel that sometimes, and frankly, I don’t quite trust anybody who would suggest they didn’t.
But we are not children. There are a lot of things we want, and many of those wants are just as primal and visceral as the above desire for painful retribution. Somebody pushes us, we want to punch them. Somebody torments our kid, we want to beat the crap out of them.
But we don’t. It’s not easy, but we don’t. It’s because we decided a long time ago, when our heads were clearer, that its wrong. Immoral. And morality, when done right – by which I mean when it’s not the nakedly self-serving, situationally-convenient morality of most right-wingers and so-called conservative Christians (the kind that tells you not to sweat it, all your impulses and biases actually just happen to line up with those of your lord & savior…. what a happy conicidence!) – is not easy. Morality is not supposed to be easy, or casual. Sometimes, sure, but when it comes to matters of intense, unreasoning passion, morality is a gauntlet.
But it’s a gauntlet that keeps us from being part of the problems in the world instead of part of the solutions.
I suspect most people in this online community understand the innate immorality of capital punishment. We may all have that moral understanding put into a vise in the coming weeks and months as the debate gets rolling (and gets angrier). But character isn’t defined by whether or not you take the moral stance when things are easy. Anybody can do that.
Moral character is a test of strength. You don’t really know the strength of that character until its put under pressure. Until then, it may just be a lot of fluffy sounding talk. And there’s plenty of that in the world already.