The always interesting Talking Points Memo has a little newsbit about former candidate John Edwards’s meetings with the two remaining presidential contenders regarding an endorsement, which the aide claims is a 50-50 possibility at this point. What’s interesting is that, while campaign observers have cast the question of an Edwards endorsement in terms of what kind of deals the former Senator may or may not make for himself, the anonymous source suggests the question for Edwards is much more about the issues – and as such is a perfect mirror of the online discussions that his former supporters have been engaged in:
The aide says he talked about “who’s going to carry on the mantle of fighting for the voiceless,” and is trying to gauge which of the two “will sign their name in blood in order to make that commitment.”…
“He’s torn,” the aide said “He has reservations about Hillary, which are pretty apparent.”
On Obama, the aide says, Edwards worries “whether he’s tough enough to be President of the United States. If you look at what Edwards ran on, which is not negotiating with the special interests, taking away their power, that’s pretty different than the Obama model.”
The Edwards aide added that Obama’s lack of a health care plan with a “mandate” is a “tough hurdle for him to get over.” He added, however, that Edwards is much more in line with Obama on other issues.
So Edwards himself is precisely where his many supporters are – conflicted. And at its core, it has less to do with Obama than Clinton herself. On domestic issues, the fact is that Clinton’s stated positions are bolder, whether it be health care, housing or the environment. The big stumbling blocks are obviously foreign policy and the continuing influence of entrenched power (from which Obama may not be a dramatic improvement – that remains to be seen), but there’s also the question of follow-through on these progressive sounding domestic proposals. Clinton has not held fast in the face of GOP pressure on domestic issues – and famously, neither did her husband for eight years.
From the perspective of this former Edwards supporter, I can’t get past this simple fact; I don’t trust her to follow through any more effectively than her last go-around with health care. Obama may well collapse like a house of cards when the other side doesn’t want to hold hands and sing campfire songs – but on the other hand, he may not.