(Non-political blogging alert!!) In terms of fantasies that have no basis in reality, yet have been believed by zillions of living breathing, human beings, Santa Claus is on a par with little else besides Iraqi WMDs, the idea that your government would never wiretap you without a warrant, and the notion that our last President did not have sexual relations with that woman (well, okay, so nobody ever really believed that last one…).
So it's the eternal parental dilemma: what do you say to your kid? Do you insist something really is true that clearly isn't? Does that set a precedent? What about kids of different ages? Do you insist your older kids play along? How and when do you decide to break the news?
And for the religious set, how does this fit into to the sacred Christmas picture? Did Jesus die for our sins, but was born for a magic man to bring presents? Could Santa have been one of the wise men? How did those wise men get there, anyway? Did anybody get a good look at that nativity star? Maybe there was a team of antlered mammals pulling it. Santa does look an awful lot like God, y'know. Old white WASPy guy with a beard. He doesn't seem quite so severe, but the real St. Nicholas was. Punched a guy out in an ecumenical council because he decided the guy was being heretical. A Huckabee voter, maybe?
But I digress. In our house, we had it easy with the first kid, who is now 8. He always insisted on the facts. Cold hard reality. He was never confident that he was really getting that, so the whole Santa thing really smelled fishy to him. His little brother, though (who is nearly 4), really grooves on that stuff, but we've avoided making it too serious a thing.
I just cant see engaging in such a charade with my kid, I'll admit. The other day when he asked if Santa was bringing presents, we told him “no, Santa's just a really nice story, like Spongebob. All your presents come from your family and friends.”
He seemed okay with that. What do you folks do? What do you non-parents think? Have I crushed my child's spirit, emotionally hobbling him forever (yeah, right)?