(A reminder to readers — I have a standing invite for pols to post diaries and I’ll front page ’em. The promotion of Sen. Dunne’s diary at the same time a poll is running on his primary race shouldn’t be misconstrued as an endorsement. – promoted by odum)
Given the emerging revelations about NSA domestic spying, I call on Lt. Governor Brian Dubie to convene an emergency session of the Governor’s Homeland Security Advisory Council to ask its members to vote on a resolution opposing domestic wire taping without a warrant, and against the secret acquisition of phone records of innocent Vermonters.
The Homeland Security Advisory Council chaired by Dubie is the appropriate entity to express to President Bush that the security of Vermonters, and the nation, is not dependent on these illegal invasions of privacy.
In January, when federal wire tapping of Vermonters’ phone calls first came to light, I sent a letter co-signed by over 100 Vermont legislators to Lt. Governor Dubie asking to formally denounce government spying on our citizens. The Lt. Governor never responded to the letter, in writing or to the press. The council has met since the letter was sent, but Chairman Dubie has yet to include it on an agenda.
The Lt. Governor should respond to every single Vermonter who takes time to write him a letter on important public matters. To ignore a request from a majority of the Vermont legislature is indefensible.
Domestic spying on Vermonters in the name of “security” is simply wrong. It violates Vermont’s proud tradition of protecting civil rights, especially the right to privacy. As the head of Vermont’s security taskforce, Dubie must stand up to Donald Rumsfeld and Dick Cheney and demand that they and the President stop spying on Vermonters.
LETTER TO LT. GOVERNOR DUBIE:
January 30, 2006
Dear Members of the Governor’s Homeland Security Advisory Council:
In the past several weeks, it has become public that the federal administration has authorized the surveillance and search of American citizens without a warrant. We strongly believe this is a fundamental infringement of our constitutional right to privacy. As the Defense Department’s monitoring of Vermonters who were peacefully sharing their political opinions demonstrates, the recent federal disregard for our civil liberties has now penetrated our own state’s borders. In the Vermont tradition, we ask you, as the representatives of our state’s Homeland Security efforts, to formally call on our national leadership to end this activity immediately.
In this post 9/11 era, the importance of an effective homeland security program is unquestioned. The dangers of terrorist may well require the use of covert efforts to identify and bring to justice those that wish to do us harm. However, effective public safety does not necessitate that we disregard our traditional and constitutional right of privacy that prohibits the government from searching our homes or monitoring our phone calls or e-mail messages without a court’s approval. Homeland security is as much about protecting our state and nation’s civil liberties and way of life as it is securing the physical safety of Vermonters.
We find the recent revelations that the national administration has utilized the resources of the federal government, including those of the National Security Agency, which was established to monitor overseas intelligence and not engage in domestic surveillance, to be shocking and deplorable. We find further that the national administration’s defense of such actions demands a swift response.
Not only do these actions challenge the basic principles of our U.S. Constitution, they specifically fly in the face of Vermont’s traditional philosophy towards the role of government. Vermonters have consistently said that no government has the right to tap our phones, read our mail, or search our homes without a good reason. We have fought strongly against such searches especially when motivated simply because a person’s views are no the same as a government official.
In 1798, one of Vermont’s U.S. Representatives, Matthew Lyon was arrested and jailed under the federal Sedition Act for his harsh written criticisms of President John Adams. But Vermonters’ respect for his actions and outrage towards an overreaching executive branch led to his reelection while he was incarcerated.
In the dark days of McCarthyism, the government used similar surveillance to find the equivalent to today’s terrorists, but then turned it into weapon to blackball people who simply had differing views on the direction of the country. Vermont U.S. Senator Ralph Flanders defied his own political party’s leadership and publicly challenged Senator McCarthy. Flander’s bold leadership laid the groundwork for the U.S. Senate’s censure of the Wisconsin Senator. His abuse of Americans’ fundamental rights became intolerable for his Senate colleagues and the nation.
As the voice for homeland security in Vermont, you are in the strongest position to oppose, on behalf of the state of Vermont,, this disregard for Vermonters’ basic rights. We hope that you will do so swiftly and strongly. With your help, we believe Vermont, under the banner of “Freedom and Unity,” can once again lead the charge to stop the Federal Government’s flagrant disregard for our fundamental civil liberties.
#30#